Is US Equity Overvalued?~Shiller vs Siegel~Roubini & Grantham bearish

I have always held  both Nobel Prize Winner & Yale Professor Robert Shiller and  Wharton Professor Jeremy Siegel in high regard on their macro views on the US Economy  and have quoted them often over the years

Their latest take on whether US Equities are overvalued pits these friends against each other.

S & P 500 is at 2100 levels and the Dow is at 18000

Shiller is concerned based on the low Valuation Confidence Index Measure on his Survey of Individual & Institutional Investors on whether they think US Equities are overvalued.The Index is at levels never seen since 2000.This low Conficence in the Market Valuation is symtomatic of a Bubble but there is no data to support this yet.It is prudent to save and diversify

Siegel on the other hand  remains bullish over the medium term and says that such high equity valuations are justified in an era of low interest rates and they are nowhere near Bubble territory

However they both agree that Bonds are overvalued though stop short of calling them in Bubble Mode

Interestingly here are some other prominent doomsayers

Dr ‘Doom’ Nouriel Roubini just stated “Market illiquidity will eventually trigger a bust and collapse” 

Here’s what another Jeremy  but a hugely bearish one ~ Jeremy Grantham of  GMO proclaimed last year

Grantham of GMO say the next Bust will be Nothing Like You Have Seen Before !

Wednesday, March 26th, 2014

Interestingly Grantham  opined in March 2014 as above that the S & P 500 may yet go higher to @ 2350 levels as the crash has historically come at an average of  @ two standard deviations from the mean…..we are 10% away from this level yet 

For those interested in assessing the consistency in views here are  my  past blogpost links to Robert Shiller

Yale Students play a prank on Nobel Laureate Robert Shiller during his Class on Macroeconomics

Saturday, July 19th, 2008
…and here is one past blogpost link  on the bullish Jeremy Siegel

Just viewed Bogle v/s Seigel…Index Investing v/s Stocks

Saturday, February 21st, 2009

How will all this effect Indian Equities ?

After our Sensex hit  a record 30000 intraday on March 4,2015 I had offered this extensive viewpoint to clients and even reiterated on ET Now on March 31,2015 that markets were running ahead of fundamentals…..a comprehensive viewpoint was posted on SCRIP STANDPOINT on my company website where I’ve said that the Sensex will slip into the lower Trading Range of 25000 to 27000 from 27000 to 29000 in the short term

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *